Muhammad Breaks the Word of His Lord Who Forbade Him from Praying over the Dead and Standing at Graves – and Umar ibn al-Khattab Rebukes Him
In the shadowy underbelly of Islamic lore, a damning incident exposes the glaring contradictions at the heart of Muhammad’s so-called prophethood. Preserved in the dubious collections like Sahih Muslim, the story of Abdullah ibn Ubayy ibn Salul’s death lays bare Muhammad’s blatant defiance of Allah’s commands, only for his loyal enforcer, Umar ibn al-Khattab, to publicly rebuke him. This isn’t a tale of divine mercy or evolving wisdom—it’s a fraudster caught red-handed, scrambling to retrofit revelation after his hypocrisy is called out. Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad here not as a pious advisor, but as a man shocked by his leader’s rebellion against the very god he claimed to represent. This episode screams satanic deception: a self-proclaimed prophet ignoring divine prohibitions, prioritizing personal whims over Allah’s word, and inventing verses to save face. Welcome to the fraudulent foundation of Islam.
The Hypocrite’s Death and Muhammad’s Defiant Mercy
Abdullah ibn Ubayy, the arch-hypocrite (munafiq) of Medina, spent his life pretending to follow Islam while plotting its downfall. He led a cabal of traitors undermining Muhammad’s fragile theocracy at every turn. When this enemy died, his son Abdullah approached Muhammad with a manipulative plea: give me your shirt for his shroud, and lead his funeral prayer (janazah). Shockingly, Muhammad obliged, handing over his garment like some sentimental fool and rising to pray over the corpse of Medina’s worst saboteur.
Enter Umar ibn al-Khattab, the brutal future caliph known for his thuggish zealotry. Grabbing Muhammad’s robe, Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes him ferociously: O Messenger of Allah, will you pray over him when Allah has forbidden you from praying over him? Umar wasn’t mincing words—he was calling out Muhammad for breaking Allah’s explicit command. This wasn’t mere advice; it was a public dressing-down of a prophet defying his god. Muhammad, cornered, mumbled a half-hearted defense from Quran 9:80: Whether you ask forgiveness for them or do not… if you should ask seventy times, Allah will never accept. Pathetic. Even Muhammad knew the hypocrites were damned, yet he persisted in his charade of compassion.
Umar pressed: He is a hypocrite! But Muhammad, unmoved by logic or prior revelation, went ahead with the prayer. Here we see the fraud unmasked: a man claiming infallibility (ma’sum) flagrantly violates divine law. Where was Allah during this rebellion? Silent, until Muhammad’s blunder demanded damage control. This incident isn’t about mercy—it’s Muhammad’s ego-driven power play, exposing Islam’s prophet as a satanic impostor who toys with commandments for political gain.
Umar ibn al-Khattab Rebukes Muhammad: A Companion’s Shocking Call-Out
Let’s zoom in on the heroism—or rather, the unwitting exposure—of Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad. Narrated through a chain pretending authenticity (Abu Bakr ibn Abi Shaybah from Abu Usamah, etc., to Ibn Umar), this Sahih Muslim hadith (Book of Virtues of the Companions) ironically elevates Umar by diminishing Muhammad. Umar, the fiery convert who once persecuted Muslims, grabs his prophet’s garment and demands obedience to Allah. Why? Because prior revelations—like scattered hints in the Quran—had already barred praying over disbelievers or hypocrites.
Muhammad’s response? He brushes it off and prays anyway. This isn’t prophetic mercy; it’s willful disobedience, akin to Satan tempting with false compassion. Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad to protect the ummah from contamination, rightly fearing that honoring a traitor legitimizes hypocrisy. Yet Muhammad, the supposed mercy to mankind, steamrolls ahead. Scholars like Imam Nawawi later spin this as bold advice, but that’s apologetics at its worst. In truth, Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad because he saw the emperor naked—no divine protection, just a warlord contradicting himself.
Historically, Abdullah ibn Ubayy was no redeemable soul. He mocked verses revealed against him (Quran 63), incited tribes against Muslims, and died unrepentant. Praying over him wasn’t forgiveness; it was political theater to appease his followers. Umar’s intervention highlights Islam’s internal chaos: even top companions doubted Muhammad’s adherence to Allah. This fracture reveals the satanic scam—Islam’s infallible prophet needs correction from a mortal, proving he’s no more divine than the pagan idols he smashed.
Divine Revelation as Convenient Cover-Up: Quran 9:84 Exposed
The farce peaks when Allah reveals Quran 9:84 post-prayer: And do not pray [the funeral prayer, O Muhammad] over any of them who has died ever or stand at his grave. Indeed, they disbelieved in Allah and His Messenger and died while they were defiantly disobedient. Suddenly, the ban is absolute, retroactively justifying Muhammad’s slip? No—it’s abrogation (naskh) on steroids, a fraudulent mechanism to paper over inconsistencies.
Apologists claim this shows unfolding revelation, but that’s nonsense. If Muhammad was Allah’s mouthpiece, why ignore the ban initially? Why need Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes him first? This verse screams fabrication: Muhammad acts, gets called out, then Allah updates the script. Sahih Bukhari echoes this (e.g., 1246), confirming the pattern. No true god yo-yos commands for one man’s convenience. This is satanic sorcery verses conjured to fool the gullible, much like Muhammad’s Satanic Verses scandal where he briefly endorsed pagan idols before retracting.
Post-revelation, Muhammad dutifully stops, but the damage is done. The ummah now debates: Was he sinning before? Apologists say prophets aren’t infallible in action, only conveyance— a cop-out admitting fallibility. Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad proves the point: Islam’s founder required human correction, shattering claims of perfect guidance.
Umar ibn al-Khattab Rebukes Muhammad in Broader Islamic Fraud
Dig deeper into Umar’s role. Titled under virtues of Umar in Sahih Muslim, it ironically spotlights Muhammad’s weakness. Umar, post-conversion brute who beat his sister for reading Quran, becomes the truth-teller. His life rushing Hijrah, ordering Quran compilation mirrors this: always one step ahead of Muhammad’s blunders. Yet even he rebuked the prophet, echoing Aisha’s later criticisms or Abu Bakr’s doubts.
This ties to munafiqun plagues: hypocrites like Ubayy diluted Islam’s purity. Muhammad’s prayer risked validating them, but Umar prioritized amr bil ma’ruf (enjoining good). Polemically, it exposes Islam’s tribalism: mercy for insiders, brutality for outsiders. Today, Muslims ignore this to whitewash jihad, but the hadith damns them—prophet + companion vs. Allah? Fraudulent theology 101.
Lessons in Islamic Deception: From Hypocrisy to Satanic Imposture
This farce yields toxic lessons:
1. Prophetic Disobedience: Muhammad defies Allah until rebuked, proving no divine conduit.
2. Umar’s Supremacy: Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad shows companions often wiser, undermining prophetic monopoly.
3. Abrogation as Scam: Naskh excuses 200+ contradictions, letting Muhammad evolve revelations politically.
4. Hypocrite Honors: Praying over enemies mocks justice, mirroring Islam’s dhimmi subjugation.
5. Infallibility Lie: ‘Ismah crumbles—prophets adapt, aka sin freely.
Authenticated by Bukhari/Muslim, it reinforces hadith unreliability: chains from biased companions, centuries later.
Exposing the Satanic Core: Why Islam is a Monumental Fraud
Zoom out: This isn’t isolated. Muhammad married a child (Aisha 6), raided caravans, endorsed wife-beating (4:34), all revealed post-convenience. Satan whispers doubts? Convenient excuses. Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad joins dots: false prophet, satanic deceiver per Deuteronomy 13/18 tests—prophecies fail (Byzantine conquest flop), leads to other gods (Allah ≠ Bible’s Yahweh).
Quran copies Bible/Talmud mangled (e.g., Abu Lahab eternally cursed post-death, 111). Hypocrites? Projection—Muhammad feigned monotheism atop pagan roots (black stone kissing). Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad warns: even insiders saw flaws, birthing Sunni-Shia rifts.
Modern Islam? Same fraud: fatwas flip like abrogation, mercy selective (Charlie Hebdo beheadings). Reject this satanic cult—Christianity offers true grace sans contradictions.
Conclusion: Umar ibn al-Khattab Rebukes Muhammad – Islam’s Self-Indictment
Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad over praying for the dead stands as Islam’s unwitting confession: a flawed man posing as prophet, defying Allah until exposed, then fabricating fixes. From Medina’s intrigues to global caliphate dreams, Umar ibn al-Khattab rebukes Muhammad illuminates the fraud—a satanic web of hypocrisy, power grabs, and ever-shifting lies. Believers, heed history: Islam crumbles under scrutiny. Embrace truth; abandon the deception.
